Oddfellows Liquor Bar Cincinnati – Best Cocktails in Over-the-Rhine

If you’re searching for a unique night out in Cincinnati, Oddfellows Liquor Bar Cincinnati should be on your radar. Nestled in the vibrant Over-the-Rhine (OTR) neighborhood at 2014 Elm Street, this spot blends the charm of a dive bar with a touch of class. It’s the kind of place where locals unwind and travelers stumble upon a memorable experience. Whether you’re craving a craft cocktail, a laid-back vibe, or a slice of pizza from next door, this bar delivers something special. Let’s dive into what makes Oddfellows a standout destination in the Queen City.

A Welcoming Spot in the Heart of Cincinnati

Oddfellows Liquor Bar sits in the historic Over-the-Rhine district, a neighborhood known for its rich history and bustling nightlife. The address, 2014 Elm Street, puts it right in the thick of things. You’ll feel the energy of OTR as soon as you step inside. The bar opened its doors in 2019, a second venture following its Columbus counterpart, spearheaded by Mikey Sorboro. Sorboro, also the brains behind Mikey’s Late Night Slice, brought his knack for creating inviting spaces to Cincinnati.

What sets this place apart? It’s not just a bar. It’s an experience. From the moment you walk in, the vintage decor catches your eye. Think of a 100-year-old wooden bar counter paired with quirky chandeliers and old-school beer coolers. It’s cozy yet bold, a mix that feels both timeless and fresh. For travelers and locals alike, it’s a spot that invites you to linger.

The Vibe – Classy Dive Bar Meets Cincinnati Cool

Oddfellows proudly calls itself a “classy dive bar,” and it lives up to that promise. The atmosphere strikes a balance between relaxed and refined. You can show up in jeans or dress up a bit – either way, you’ll fit right in. The interior feels like a nod to the past, with its antique touches and eclectic decor. But there’s a modern edge too, thanks to the creative energy flowing through OTR.

Picture this. You’re sitting at a table, sipping a cocktail, surrounded by walls that tell a story. Maybe you’re out with friends, or maybe you’re a solo traveler soaking in the local scene. Either way, the vibe is unpretentious. It’s the kind of place where everyone feels welcome, from Cincinnati regulars to first-time visitors exploring the city.

And then there’s the outdoor patio. When the weather’s right, it’s a perfect spot to kick back with a drink. The patio adds an extra layer of charm, especially on warm Ohio evenings. It’s not fancy, but it’s got character – just like the rest of Oddfellows.

Drinks That Steal the Show

Let’s talk about the drinks. At Oddfellows Liquor Bar Cincinnati, the cocktail menu is where the magic happens. These aren’t your average bar pours. The bartenders here craft cocktails with care, blending creativity with flavor. Ever tried a Negroni Slush? It’s a fan favorite, cool and refreshing with a bitter kick. Or how about Bloodhounds & Vultures? The name alone sparks curiosity, and the taste backs it up.

Beyond cocktails, the beer selection shines too. They rotate fresh drafts regularly, so there’s always something new to try. Whether you’re into local brews or just want a cold one to sip, you won’t be disappointed. And if spirits are more your speed, they’ve got a solid lineup of classics and surprises.

The best part? Prices won’t break the bank. This isn’t a high-end lounge with sky-high tabs. It’s a bar that keeps things reasonable, making it easy to enjoy a night out without wincing at the bill. For travelers watching their budget or locals looking for a go-to spot, that’s a big win.

Food – Small Bites and a Pizza Bonus

Now, Oddfellows isn’t a full-on restaurant, but it’s got enough to keep your stomach happy. The food menu is small and quirky, leaning into bar-friendly snacks with a twist. Pickled eggs are a standout – tangy, bold, and perfect with a drink. Then there’s the Sriracha hummus, a spicy take on a classic that pairs well with a cold beer. And don’t sleep on the bacon brittle. It’s sweet, crunchy, and smoky all at once, a little treat that’s hard to resist.

But here’s the real game-changer. Oddfellows shares a wall with Mikey’s Late Night Slice, a Cincinnati pizza legend. Craving a late-night slice? Just pop next door or order it right to your table. The combo of cocktails and pizza is a match made in heaven, especially after a few rounds. It’s a perk that locals love and travelers quickly catch onto. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in for the night, this setup makes Oddfellows a one-stop spot.

Events That Keep the Night Alive

Oddfellows Liquor Bar Cincinnati knows how to keep things lively. The bar hosts events that draw a crowd and add some fun to your visit. Karaoke nights are a big hit – nothing beats belting out a tune with a drink in hand. Then there’s live music, featuring local bands that bring the OTR spirit to life. If you’re lucky, you might catch a trivia night, where you can test your knowledge and maybe win a round on the house.

They also mix it up with special events. Think themed parties like Mad Hatters or something as wild as a drunk spelling bee. These nights give the bar a playful edge, making every visit a little different. For tourists, it’s a chance to see Cincinnati’s creative side. For locals, it’s a reason to keep coming back. Check their social media or call ahead at 513-258-0518 to see what’s on the calendar during your trip.

The Hidden Button – A Fun Surprise

Here’s a little insider tip. Oddfellows has a secret up its sleeve – a hidden button somewhere in the bar. Find it, press it, and you’ll score a free glass of champagne. It’s a small thrill that adds to the experience. No one’s spilling where it is, so you’ll have to explore a bit. Ask the staff for a hint if you’re feeling stuck, but half the fun is the hunt.

This quirky touch fits the bar’s personality perfectly. It’s not just about drinking – it’s about the stories you’ll take home. Whether you’re a visitor snapping pics for Instagram or a Cincinnatian showing off your city, that button’s a detail you won’t forget.

What Visitors Say

People love Oddfellows for its vibe and charm, but it’s not without its quirks. Regulars rave about the spacious layout and cool decor. The patio gets plenty of praise too, especially in summer. Pairing drinks with Mikey’s pizza is a highlight for many, and the staff often gets a nod for being friendly and quick when the crowd’s light.

That said, it’s not perfect. Some folks mention spotty service when the place fills up, especially on weekends. A few have grumbled about early closings despite the 2:30 AM cutoff. And if you’re sensitive to noise, karaoke or live music nights might feel loud. Still, the positives outweigh the hiccups for most. It’s a bar with personality, and that’s what keeps people coming through the door.

Practical Info for Your Visit

Planning a stop at Oddfellows Liquor Bar Cincinnati? Here’s what you need to know. They’re open Monday to Friday from 4:00 PM to 2:30 AM, and weekends from noon to 2:30 AM. That late-night window makes it a great pick for night owls. You can reach them at 513-258-0518 or email [email protected] for questions or event details.

Payment’s easy – they take credit cards, debit, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. Want to grab something to go? They offer takeout, though delivery isn’t an option. The bar’s in a walkable part of OTR, so parking might take a little patience. But once you’re there, it’s worth it.

Why Oddfellows Stands Out

Cincinnati’s nightlife is full of choices, from breweries to upscale lounges. So why pick Oddfellows? It’s the mix of old-school cool and modern flair. It’s the cocktails that surprise you and the pizza joint next door that seals the deal. It’s a bar that feels like a local hangout but welcomes travelers with open arms.

For tourists, it’s a taste of Over-the-Rhine’s soul – historic, lively, and a little offbeat. For Cincinnatians, it’s a spot to unwind or kick off a big night. Oddfellows Liquor Bar Cincinnati isn’t just a place to drink – it’s a place to feel the city’s pulse. Next time you’re in town, swing by 2014 Elm Street. You might just find that hidden button – and a new favorite spot.